← Back
Antileukemic activity and cellular effects of rhodium(III) crown thiaether complexes.
Biometals(2011)24:645–661
DOI10.1007/s10534-011-9414-9
Antileukemic activity and cellular effects of rhodium(III)
crown thiaether complexes
Ruth Bieda • Igor Kitanovic • Hamed Alborzinia •
Andreas Meyer • Ingo Ott • Stefan Wo¨lfl •
William S. Sheldrick
Received:31October2010/Accepted:12January2011/Publishedonline:28January2011
(cid:2)SpringerScience+BusinessMedia,LLC.2011
Abstract The cytostatic properties of novel rho- with LL = bpm, dpq, and 1,4-dithiane. The order of
dium(III) thiacrown ether complexes [RhCl(LL)([9] activity (bpm[1,4-dithiane[dpq[bpy) contrasts
aneS )]n?witheitheraromaticj2Nligands(n = 2)or tothatobservedforadhesivecancercells(bpm[bpy,
3
anionicchelateligands(n = 1)havebeeninvestigated 1,4-dithiane[dpq). Necrosis is insignificant in
forthehumancancercelllinesHT-29andMCF-7and all cases. The percentage of Jurkat cells exhibiting
for immortalized HEK-293 cells. Taken together apoptosisafter24or48 hincubationperiodsisdirectly
with literature IC values for analogous complexes correlated to the percentage of cells exhibiting high
50
with polypyridyl ligands or 1,4-dithiane, the in vitro levels of reactive oxygen species. As established by
assays indicate that dicationic complexes with soft onlinemonitoringwithasensorchipsystem,treatment
j2N (imino) or j2S (thiaether) ligands exhibit signif- of MCF-7 cells with the bpm and 1,4-dithiane com-
icantlyhigherantiproliferativeeffectsthanthosewith plexesleadstoasignificantandpermanentconcentra-
hard j2N (amino) ligands. Dicationic complexes are tion-dependent decrease in oxygen consumption and
moreactivethanmonocationiccomplexeswithsimilar cellularadhesion.
ligands. Pronounced apoptosis-inducing properties
towards Jurkat cells were established for complexes Keywords Rhodium (cid:2) Thiacrown ether (cid:2)
Cytotoxicity (cid:2) Leukemia (cid:2) Apoptosis (cid:2) ROS
Electronicsupplementarymaterial Theonlineversionof
thisarticle(doi:10.1007/s10534-011-9414-9)contains
supplementarymaterial,whichisavailabletoauthorizedusers. Introduction
R.Bieda(cid:2)W.S.Sheldrick(&)
Selective treatment is a prerequisite for all oncolog-
Lehrstuhlfu¨rAnalytischeChemie,Ruhr-Universita¨t
icaldrugsintumortherapy.Astherearecurrentlyno
Bochum,44780Bochum,Germany
e-mail:william.sheldrick@rub.de tumor therapeutic drugs known without serious side-
effects, a high level of current interest is present for
I.Kitanovic(cid:2)H.Alborzinia(cid:2)S.Wo¨lfl
research on novel cell selective drugs. Metal com-
Institutfu¨rPharmazieundMolekulareBiotechnologie,
pounds can display an advantageous chemical func-
Ruprecht-Karls-Universita¨tHeidelberg,ImNeuenheimer
Feld364,69120Heidelberg,Germany tionality and are currently of increasing interest in
medical chemistry, both as diagnostic agents and as
A.Meyer(cid:2)I.Ott
drugs(Jakupecetal.2008;OttandGust2007;Clarke
Institutfu¨rPharmazeutischeChemie,Technische
2002). Only three metal based compounds, cisplatin,
Universita¨tBraunschweig,Beethovenstraße55,
38106Braunschweig,Germany carboplatin and oxaliplatin, are currently in use as
123
646 Biometals(2011)24:645–661
antitumordrugs,andallofthesecontainplatinum(II) sequences,whereastheirstructuralanalogue[Rh([12]
as the central metal atom. Cisplatin, the most aneS )(phi)]3?withtheHacceptorthiaethercoligand
4
successful metal-containing antitumor therapeutic [12]ane-S doesnot(ShieldsandBarton1995).Upon
4
agent (Rosenberg et al. 1969) is especially active irradiation at 311 nm, the phototoxic and photonuc-
towards testicular and ovarian cancer. Nephro-, oto- lease agent [RhCl (dppz)(phen)]Cl exhibits toxicity
2
and neurotoxicity are unfortunate side-effects, which towards the tumor cell lines GN4, M109 and KB
restrict its clinical utility to a certain extent. Repre- (Menonetal.2004).
sentativeexamplesofnon-platinummetal-containing Recent work on the possible anticancer activity of
compoundscurrentlyinclinicaltrialsare(ImH)[trans- otherrhodium(III)polypyridylcomplexeshasproduced
{RhCl (DMSO)(Im)}] (NAMI-A) and (IndH)[trans- some highly promising results. Systematic studies on
4
{RhCl (Ind) }] (KP1019) (Jakupec et al. 2008). the cytotostatic properties of the compounds mer-
4 2
Whereas the high effectiveness of NAMI-A against [RhCl (DMSO)(pp)] and [(C Me )RhCl(pp)](CF SO )
3 5 5 3 3
metastases is related to a combination of its anti- (pp = bpy,phen,dpq = dipyrido[3,2-d:20,30-f]quinoxa-
angionesisandanti-invasivepropertiesagainsttumor line, dppz, dppn) have demonstrated that the in vitro
cellsandvasculature(Morbidellietal.2003),KP1019 antiproliferative activities of these contrasting types of
enteredclinicaltrialsforitsactivityagainstcolorectal rhodium(III)complexes towards thehumancancer cell
cancer and their metastases (Hartinger et al. 2006; lines HT-29 (colon carcinoma) and MCF-7 (breast
Rademaker-Lakhai et al. 2004). It has been reported, carcinoma) increase with increasing polypyridyl ligand
that KP1019 can influence the mitochondrial mem- size (Harlos et al. 2008; Scharwitz et al. 2008). The
brane stability and can activate caspase-3, which is meridional trichlorido complexes are extremely potent
well-known for its induction of apoptosis by the and exhibit IC values in the range 0.051–0.095 lM
50
mitochondrial pathway (Kapitza et al. 2005). towards the MCF-7 and HT-29 cell lines for the larger
Transition metal complexes containing polypyridyl polypyridyl ligands pp = dpq, dppz, dppn = benzo[i]
(pp)ligandshaverecentlyreceivedconsiderableatten- dipyrido[3,2-a:20,30-c]phenazine (Dobroschke et al.
tionaspotentialdiagnosticagentsowingtotheirability 2009). Significant levels of cell cytotoxicity have
torecognizeandbindatspecificbasesequencesinDNA also been reported for other rhodium(III) compounds
(Erkkila et al. 1999; Metcalfe and Thomas 2003). including mer-[RhCl (tpy)] (tpy = 2,20:6,200-terpyri-
3
Octahedral Ru(II) and Rh(III) compounds containing dine) (Pruchnik et al. 2002), fac-[RhCl ([9]aneNS )]
3 2
the smaller ligands 2,20-bipyridine (bpy) or 1,10- ([9]aneNS = 1-aza-4,7-dithiacyclononane) (Medvetz
2
phenanthroline (phen) have been shown to be groove et al. 2007) and polypyridyl complexes of the types
binders or possible partial intercalators (Erkkila et al. [RhCl(pp)([9]aneS )]2?([9]aneS = 1,4,7-trithiacyclo-
3 3
1999;Zeglisetal.2007).Forlargerpolypyridylligands nonane) (Bieda et al. 2009a) and [RhCl(pp)(tpm)]2?
like phi (9,10-diaminophenanthroline) (Sitlani et al. (tpm = tris(pyrazolyl)methane) (Bieda et al. 2009b)
1992) and dppz (dipyrido[2,3-a:20,30-c]phenazine) towards adhesive human cancer cell lines. We now
(Frodletal.2002)strongintercalativebindinghasoften report an extension of our previous studies on rho-
beenestablished. dium(III) crown thiaether compounds to aromatic
[Rh(phi) (phen)]3?and[Rh(phi)(phen) ]3?bothdis- dinitrogen ligands other than pp (complexes 1–4)
2 2
play nuclease activity. Whereas [Rh(phi) (phen)]3? (Scheme 1)andtobidentateanionicligands(complexes
2
cleaves in a sequence neutral manner, [Rh(phi) 5 and 6) (Scheme 2). Particular emphasis has been
(phen) ]3? cleaves 50-pyr-pyr-pur-30 sequences selec- placed on the biological impact of ([9]aneS )Rh(III)
2 3
tively possibly due to its steric and van der Waals complexesonnon-adhesiveleukemiacells.
interactionswithinthemajorgroove[Sitlanietal.1992).
These findings underline the possible influence of the
ancillary ligands on both the DNA binding and the Results and discussion
biologicalpropertiesofrhodiumpolypyridylcomplexes.
The important role of ancillary ligands in enabling Synthesis and structure
specificDNAsitebindingisalsodemonstratedbytheH
donorligandsenand[12]aneN in[Rh(en) (phi)]3?and An in situ preparation procedure was established for
4 2
[Rh([12]aneN )(phi)]3?, which can recognize 50-GC-30 the novel ([9]aneS )RhIII complexes of the type
4 3
123
Biometals(2011)24:645–661 647
2+ Aromatic diamines of various lengths and shapes
wereemployedasligandsin2–4toestablishwhether
S
the activity of these complexes is significantly
S N different from that of compounds containing the
Rh
larger polypyridyl ligands dpqanddppz.Theligands
S N phi, naphdiamine and dab exhibit the ability to bind
Cl
tometalatomseitherasdiiminesunderabstractionof
twoprotonsorastertiarydiamines.Inthecaseofthe
COOH
H ([9]aneS )RhIII compounds 2–4, only 9,10-diamin-
3
N N H N
2 ophenanthrene lost two amino protons during the
coordination process to produce the diimino phi
N H N H 2 N complex2,asestablishedbyLSIMSanalysis.TheIR
4 spectrum of 2 lacks a strong d(NH ) band in the
COOH 2
1 2 3 typical 1,550–1,640 cm-1 range for amino com-
plexes and contains only the characteristic weak
Scheme1 Structuresofthecomplexes1–4
intensity bands for coordinated phi, namely d(N–H)
at 1,501 cm-1 and t(C=N) at 1,604 cm-1, near to or
-
+ in this range (Madureira et al. 2000). For the
S - N naphdiamine and dab complexes 3 and 4, LSIMS
S dataclearlyindicateadiaminocoordination,whichis
S L confirmed by the presence ofstrong t(NH )bands in
2
Rh S the range 3,250–3,000 cm-1 and strong d(NH )
2
S L 5 bands between 1,610 and 1,550 cm-1 in both of
Cl 6 their IR spectra, e.g. t(NH ) at 3,169, 3,134, 3,091
2
and3,045 cm-1andd(NH )at1,608and1,553 cm-1
2
Scheme2 Structuresofthecomplexes5and6
for the naphdiamine complex 3. The phenomenon of
Ru-assisted proton abstraction and diimine coordina-
[RhCl(LL)([9]aneS )]2?1–4(LL = bpy-4,40-(COOH) , tion has been previously reported for phi and dab
3 2
phi, naphdiamine, dab,) and [RhCl(phenylpy)([9] compounds (Madureira et al. 2000).
aneS )]? 6 in accordance to that employed for the Pronounced antiproliferative activity (IC \12.8
3 50
previously published compounds [RhCl(LL)([9] lM) against MCF-7 and HT-29 cells has previously
aneS )]2?7–14(LL = bpy,bpm =2,20-bipyrimidine, been established for ([9]aneS )RhIII complexes con-
3 3
phen, tap = pyrazino[2,3-f]quinoxaline, dpq, dppz, tainingthej2Sligand1,4-dithiane(Biedaetal.2010)
pip = piperazine, 1,4- dithiane) (Bieda et al. 2009a; and the smallest pp ligand 2,20-bipyridine (Bieda
2010).TreatmentofRhCl (cid:2)3H Owiththeappropriate et al. 2009a). We have now employed the anionic
3 2
bidentate(pp)ligand ineitherCH OH,H O,CH Cl j2S ligand dmdtc- in ([RhCl(dmdtc)[9]aneS )]? 5
3 2 2 2 3
or CH OH/CH Cl (L) afforded the intermediate and the 2-phenylpyridine ligand phenylpy- in
3 2 2
complexes [RhCl (pp)(L)] in situ which were then [RhCl(phenylpy)([9]aneS )]Cl 6 to establish whether
3 3
employed without further separation or characteriza- reducing the overall complex charge to ?1 will lead
tion for the preparation of the [9]aneS complexes. to an increase in activity due to a possible improve-
3
Compound[RhCl(dmdtc)([9]aneS )]?5wassynthes- ment in cellular uptake.
3
ised by addition of Na(dmdtc) (dmdtc = dim-
ethyldithiocarbamate) to [RhCl (MeCN)([9]aneS )]? DNA interaction studies
2 3
(Bieda et al. 2010) in analogy to the literature
procedureforsimilarcomplexeswiththedithiocarba- DNA interactions of the ([9]aneS )RhIII complexes
3
mate ligands R NCS - (R = CH CH , PhCH ) 1–6 were investigated together with those of the pre-
2 2 3 2 2
(Brandt and Sheldrick 1996). Complexes 1–6 were viously reported complexes [RhCl(pip)([9]aneS )]2?
3
characterizedby1HNMRandpositive-ionLSIMSand 13 and [RhCl(1,4-dithiane)([9]aneS )]2? 14 by CD
3
gavesatisfactorymicroanalyses. and UV/Vis spectroscopy. Whereas half-sandwich
123
648 Biometals(2011)24:645–661
organometalliccomplexeswithlabilechlorideligands 275 nm due to base stacking are observed. Changes
typically bind to nucleobase nitrogen atoms (Annen induced by specific interactions between the biomol-
et al. 2000; Sheldrick et al. 1993), those of the type ecule and the aromatic ligand of the transition metal
[(g5-C Me )RhCl(pp)]? (pp = dpq, dppz) are strong complexes can induce CD bands between 280 and
5 5
intercalatorsintoDNA(HerebianandSheldrick2002; 400 nmasaresultofintercalation,surfaceorgroove
Scharwitzetal.2008),andsuchabindinginteraction binding. Only very minor changes in the DNA
has also been established for [RhCl(pp)([9]aneS )]2? conformation were established on addition of the
3
and[RhCl(pp)(tpm)]2?(pp = dpq,dppz)(Biedaetal. compounds 1, 2 or 6. Small differences are apparent
2009a, b). Following initial incubation periods of in Fig. S1 for the induced CD signal related to the
5 min, UV/Vis spectra of buffered solutions of com- base stacking of CT DNA in the presence of 5 or 14
plexes1–6(10 mMphosphatebuffer,pH = 7.2)with {r = [complex]/[DNA] = 0.2 for [DNA] = M (bp)}
calf thymus DNA (CT DNA) at 25(cid:3)C and r = 0.1 in a 10 mM phosphate buffer. The molar ellipticity
exhibited no further significant changes over 6 h, [h] decreased by 10% for 5 but increased by 5% for
thereby indicating that achievement of equilibrium 14 at the maximum of the positive CD band at
mustberapid.Effectivelynoabsorptionchangeswere 275 nm.
observedforcomplexes[RhCl(LL)([9]aneS )]n?1–5, Smalldecreasesintheellipticityvalueforthebase
3
13 and 14 on mixing with CT DNA. Only minor stackingsignalwerealsoobservedforCTDNAinits
changes (DA/A = 0.05 and 0.06) in the DNA mixtureswith2or4(Fig. 1).Instrikingcontrast,the
max
absorbance band between 250 and 260 nm were CD spectrum of compound 13 with CT DNA at
observedfor6duringtheinitialmixingperiod. r = 0.2 displayed a pronounced decrease of 52% in
DNA melting point changes in the presence of a the magnitude of the band related to base stacking.
metalcompoundprovideastraightforwardmethodof Whereas the helix conformation is apparently little
establishing the strength of DNA binding. The DT affectedbythisinteraction,thebasestackingsignalis
m
valuesforCTDNAinthepresenceofthecompounds reduced to nearly half its original value. This change
[RhCl(LL)([9]aneS )]n?1–6were?2,?3,-2,-1,0 could result from covalent binding of the rhodium
3
and ?1(cid:3)C, respectively. The negative thermal dena- fragment to the double helix, for which additional
turation temperature changes of -2 and -1(cid:3)C evidence is provided by the observed DT value of
m
invoked by the diamino complexes 3 and 4 are in -2(cid:3)C. Although this compound causes significant
accordance with an absence of intercalation by their changesintheDNAconformation,itdoesnotexhibit
aromaticligands.Incontrast, thecompounds 1and2 significant cytostatic activity (IC [100 lM)
50
with positive DT values of ?2 and ?3(cid:3)C may towards the adenomacarcinoma MCF-7 and HT-29
m
exhibit groove binding or a limited degree of cells.Incontrast,whereasthediimino phicomplex2
intercalation. Following the loss of two amino causesonlyminorchangesforboththecharacteristic
protons during the synthesis of compound 2, its DNA CD signals, it invokes relatively low IC
50
planar phi ligand can potentially interact with CT values of 19.20 (2.19) lM and 11.96 (1.93) lM in
DNA in a manner similar to that of the diimino MCF-7 and HT-29.
polypyridyl ligands of complexes 9–12. It is inter-
esting to note that DT values of zero were recorded
m
for the j2S coordinated compounds 5 and 14. Both Cellular effects
compounds have, therefore, no significant effect on
the stability of the DNA. Antiproliferative activity towards adhesive MCF-7,
In the presence of small molecules, characteristic HT-29 and HEK-293 cells
changesinthecirculardicroism(CD)spectraofDNA
in the range of 220–400 nm can provide a means of In vitro studies on the antiproliferative activities of
monitoring possible conformational changes for the compounds of the type [RhCl(LL)([9]aneS )]n? 1–6
3
biopolymer(Brabecetal.1990;ErikssonandNorden were carried out with the human MCF-7 (breast
2001). CT DNA is present in the B DNA form for cancer) and HT-29 (colon cancer) cell lines and the
which a negative CD band at 246 nm caused by the resulting IC values are listed in Table 1 together
50
helical conformation and a positive CD band at with those for the ligands LL in Table 2. Estimated
123
Biometals(2011)24:645–661 649
Fig.1 CD spectra of CT DNA and mixtures of [DNA]=0.2 for [DNA]=M (bp)} in a 10mM phosphate
[RhCl(phi)([9]aneS )]Cl 2, [RhCl(dab)([9]aneS )]Cl 4 and buffer (pH=7.2) after an incubation period of 1h. Molar
3 2 3 2
[RhCl(pip)([9]aneS )]Cl 13 with CT DNA {r=[complex]/ ellipticities[h]aregivenintheunitsdegcm2dmol-1910-3
3 2
Table1 IC (lM)valuesforthecomplexes[RhCl(LL)([9]aneS )]n?1–14
50 3
Compound LL Counterions MCF-7IC HT-29IC HEK-293IC
50 50 50
1 bpy-4,40(COOH) Cl [100 [100 [100
2 2
2 Phi Cl 19.20(2.19) 11.96(1.93) 26.1(5.0)
2
3 Naphdiamine Cl 18.06(3.42) 50.7(5.8) [100
2
4 Dab Cl [100 [100 [100
2
5 Dmdtc CF SO 33.1(2.1) 40(27) 94.1(0.5)
3 3
6 Phenylpy Cl 57.3(9.0) 51.6(17.3) 54.1(7.2)
7a Bpy Cl 12.8(0.2) 4.4(0.1) [100
2
8a Bpm Cl 1.7(0.5) 1.9(0.1) 0.6(0.2)
2
9a Phen [PF ] 36.3(6.0) 72.2(8.0) [100
62
10a Tap Cl 11.5(0.6) 7.6(4.8) 3.3(1.3)
2
11a Dpq Cl 19.1(0.3) 20.9(2.8) 45.5(1.9)
2
12a Dppz Cl 4.7(0.5) 7.4(2.2) 8.9(1.6)
2
13b Pip Cl [100 [100 [100
2
14b Dithiane Cl 9.6(2.2) 8.1(3.7) 11.6(2.9)
2
Estimatedstandarddeviationsaregiveninparentheses
a Biedaetal.(2009a)
b Biedaetal.(2010)
standard deviations are given in parentheses. To The expected trend of increasing antiproliferative
determine a possible cell selectivity of facial Rh(III) activity with increasing length of the polypyridyl
compounds towards cancer cell lines, these com- ligand (Scha¨fer et al. 2007) has been established for
pounds were also tested towards immortalized HEK- the analogous tpm compounds (Bieda et al. 2009b)
293 (human embryonic kidney) cells (Table 1). againstthecancercelllinesMCF-7andHT-29andin
123
650 Biometals(2011)24:645–661
Table2 IC (lM)valuesforselectedligands established for complex 3 with its larger aromatic
50
surface area. As no activity was observed towards
Ligand MCF-7IC HT-29IC HEK-293IC
50 50 50
HEK-293 cells, it is apparent that the cell lines
bpy(COOH) [100 [100 ND exhibitincreasingsensitivitytowardsthiscomplexin
2
phi 19.5(1.5) 15.6(3.0) 29.2(9.6) the order MCF-7[HT-29 (cid:3) HEK-293, which may
naphdiamine 43.9(29.0) 63.5(4.5) [100 berelatedtothecytotostaticpropertiesofthediamino
dab 37.0(12.6) 58.8(16.6) 65.6(4.0) ligandonitsown.Fornaphdiamineitself,IC values
50
phenylpy [100 [100 [100 of 43.9(29.0) and 63.5(4.5) lM were observed
Cisplatina 2.0(0.3) 7.0(2.0) 2.6(0.6) towards MCF-7 and HT-29 cells, respectively, but
theIC valuewasgreaterthan100 lMforHEK-293
Estimatedstandarddeviationsaregiveninparentheses 50
cells.
a Scharwitzetal.(2008)
Apoptosis induction in the leukemia cell lines
the case of the [9]aneS compounds for 9, 11 and 12 K562 and Jurkat
3
containing the larger polypyridyl ligands phen, dpq
and dppz (Bieda et al. 2009a). This trend is also Weextendedthebiologicalstudieson([9]aneS )RhIII
3
followed by the IC values for the ([9]aneS )RhIII complexes to the non-adhesive leukaemia cell lines
50 3
compounds towards HEK-293 cells. A different K562andJurkat.Thecompounds7,8,10,11and14
mechanism of action was postulated for compounds were selected on the basis of their relatively high
containing the nitrogen-rich bpm and tap ligands on antiproliferative activities (Table 1) towards the
thebasisoftheirhighantiproliferativeactivity(Bieda adhesive cell lines MCF7 and HT-29 and their
et al. 2010). The results presented in Table 1 allow differingtypesofbidentateligands.Apoptosisinduc-
two structure–activity relationships tobeestablished. tion was tested for K562 (human chronic myeloge-
Firstly,complexescontainingdiaminoligandsare,in nous leukemia) and Jurkat cells (human T-cell
general, less active than j2N (imino) coordinated leukemia) by an Annexin V/propidium iodide assay
complexes.Secondly,asexemplifiedbycomplex6in and PARP cleavage. The biological impact of the
comparison to its j2N (imino) analogue 7, overall compounds was followed by measuring the intracel-
charge reduction from ?2 to ?1 appears to lead to a lular level of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and by
loss of activity. It is interesting to note, in this online monitoring of cellular metabolic processes.
respect, that following deprotonation of its carboxyl- In apoptotic cells, phosphatidylserine is translo-
ate functions, the inactive complex 1 will exhibit catedfromtheinnertotheouterleafletoftheplasma
overall neutrality at biologically relevant pH values. membrane,therebyexposingittotheexternalcellular
Howeverareducedlevelofcellularuptakecouldalso environment(vanEngelandetal.1998),whereitcan
beresponsibleforitslackofantiproliferativeactivity. be detected by its binding to the intracellular protein
IC values[100 lM towards all three cell lines Annexin V (Andree et al. 1990), labeled with a
50
wereestablishedforthediaminocomplexes4and13. fluorophore (Koopman et al. 1994). An Annexin V
In comparison, the diimino phi complex 2 exhibits assayisabletodistinguishapoptoticcellsfromviable
valuesof19.20(2.19)(MCF-7),11.96(1.93)(HT-29) or necrotic cells on the basis of the resulting fluores-
and26.1(5.0) lM(HEK-293),thatarecomparableto cence of the former cells. A simultaneous dead cell
those of the dpq complex 11. When compared to the stainemploysthefluorochromepropidiumiodide(PI),
likewise very similar values of 19.5 (1.5) and 15.6 that can only penetrate dead or dying cells that have
(3.0) lM for the ligand itself towards MCF-7 and lost or are losing membrane integrity. PI intercalates
HT-29cells,itcanbepostulatedthattheactivityof2 intoDNAtoproduceahighlyfluorescentadduct,that
may primarily be due to the spatial and stacking enables a precise evaluation of cellular DNA content
properties of the phi ligand on its own. Whereas the by flow cytometric analysis (Lecoeur 2002; Riccardi
dab compound 4 exhibits no significant antiprolifer- and Nicoletti 2006). PI positivity is an indicator of
ative activity towards either MCF-7 or HT-29 cells eitherlateapoptosisornecrosis.
(IC [100), IC values of 18.06 (3.42) lM and Annexin V/PI assays were first performed for
50 50
50.7 (5.8) lM towards the cancer cell lines were K562 cells with complexes 7, 10 and 11. After 48 h
123
Biometals(2011)24:645–661 651
incubation periods with concentrations of 10, 20 and
40 lM, the cells were, however, only affected in a
minor fashion (data not shown). The percentage of
viable cells was higher than 80% in all cases. Mock
(solvent of the highest concentration) and 5 lM
CMPT (camptothecin) samples were employed as
controls.AssayswerethencarriedoutforJurkatcells
after 24 and 48 h incubation periods with the same
complexes. No significant apoptosis was determined
after 24 h, which indicates that reduced cell viability
is a time-dependent process (data not shown).
Fig.2 Annexin V/PI assay towards Jurkat cells illustrating
Figure 2 depicts the state of the Jurkat cells for each
thenumberofcells/mlfollowingtheir48htreatmentwiththe
of the three compounds in correlation to the number compounds 7, 10 and 11 at various concentrations. N gives
of cells/ml present after the 48 h incubation periods. the number of cells/ml. Mock (solvent of the highest
Allthreecompoundsreducedthetotalcellnumberin concentration)and5lMcamptothercin(CMPT)sampleswere
employedascontrols
a concentration-dependent manner. In comparison to
the control value of nearly 6 9 105 cells/ml, com-
pound 7 containing the smaller bpy ligand lowered cells correlating to increasing relative amounts of
thenumbersofcellsonlygraduallyindependenceon early and late apoptotic cells were more apparent for
its concentration to a final cell number of nearly compound 10 and particularly for 11 after the longer
4 9 105 cells/ml for a 40 lM solution. After treat- incubationperiod.Compound11inducesapoptosisin
ment with a 10 lM solution of the tap complex 10, a clearly concentration-dependent manner. After a
the viable cell number was lowered to about 5.3 9 48 h incubation with a 10 lM solution of 11, 87%
105 cells/ml and this value was further reduced to viable Jurkat cells were established, for a 20 lM
about 3.5 9 105 cells/ml at a concentration of concentration 74% and for a 40 lM concentration
40 lM. The most pronounced cell number decrease only 63%. In conclusion, the data of the Annexin
was determined in the case of complex 11 with the V/PI assay for the compounds 7, 10 and 11 towards
largest polypyridyl ligand. After treatment with a the Jurkat cells demonstrate that with increasing size
10 lM concentration of the dpq complex about of the polypyridyl ligand (bpy\tap\dpq) increas-
2.9 9 105 cells/ml were still viable. Only 2 9 105 ing apoptosis induction is invoked within a 48 h
cells/ml were viable in the case of a 20 lM solution incubation period, whereas after 24 h no significant
and this number fell to 1.4 9 105 cells/ml for the apoptosis induction could be established. This order
40 lM solution. The extent of apoptosis induction ofactivitycontraststothatobservedfortheadhesive
was not as high as observed for the CMPT control, MCF-7 and HT-29 cells (dpq\bpy\tap) and
but the reduction in the number of cells/ml to about suggests that cell-type differences in the mechanism
only a quarter of the control value is indicative of of action may play a role.
pronounced anti-proliferative properties of the dpq- These findingspromptedustostudytheimpact of
containing ([9]aneS )RhIII complex towards Jurkat two further rhodium(III) complexes 8 and 14 on
3
cells. It is interesting to note that complex 11 has a Jurkat leukemia cells. The former bpm complex
markedly lower antiproliferative effect towards the exhibits the lowest IC values of all previously
50
adhesivecelllinesMCF-7andHT-29thancomplexes tested ([9]aneS )Rh(III)complexes (Table 1)and the
3
7 and 10 (Table 1). The findings of Fig. 2 therefore latter compound contains an aliphatic j2S chelate
indicate an increased sensitivity of Jurkat cells ligandratherthanthearomaticj2N(imino)ligandsof
towards 11 in comparison to 7 and 10. 7, 8, 10 and 11.
Effectively no cell death inducing properties were In the case of complex 8 a high antiproliferative
established for compound 7 towards the Jurkat cells. activity was also established for the non-adhesive
The percentage of viable cells decreased only mar- Jurkatcells(Fig. 3).Nonecroticcellswereobserved.
ginallyfrom96to93%withincreasingconcentration Evenatthelowestconcentrationof1.25 lM,thecell
(10–40 lM) of 7. Decreasing percentages of viable number was reduced after 48 h to about a half in
123
652 Biometals(2011)24:645–661
PARP cleavage assay
For confirmation of caspase activity and apoptosis
induction,WesternBlot analyses were performed for
possible PARP cleavage products. The DNA repair
enzyme PARP [poly (ADP-Ribose) polymerase] is
expressed more in apoptotic cells due to DNA
fragmentation and is cleaved by caspases, especially
Fig.3 AnnexinV/PIassaytowardsJurkatcellsillustratingthe by caspase-3 in vivo (Nicholson et al. 1995). The
number of cells/ml following their 48h treatment with the inhibition and cleavage of PARP protein can there-
compound [RhCl(bpm)([9]aneS )]2? 8 at various concentra-
3 fore be considered as being molecular markers for
tions.Ngivesthenumberofcells/ml
caspase-mediated apoptosis. An antibody against
comparison to the mock control sample. At 20 lM PARP can detect intact PARP (116 kDa) and its
only 1.0 9 105 cells/ml were present in comparison cleavage products (89 and 24 kDa). Western Blot
to 3.6 9 105 cells/ml for the control. Following analysis for anti-b-actin obtained from the same
treatment with a 5 lM solution nearly all cells were membranewasusedasaloadingcontroltoverifythe
in an early or late apoptotic state. On increasing the total protein content. The Western Blot analyses of
concentrationupto10and20 lM,thepercentagesof possible cleavage products of the PARP protein in
cells undergoing early or late apoptosis were compa- Jurkat cells after a 24 h treatment at the indicated
rable to those found for cells treated with CMPT at concentrations of the substances 11 and 7 are
10 lM. depicted in Fig. 5. This pair was chosen to enable a
Figure 4 illustrates the numbers of Jurkat cells/ml comparison of possible caspase activity for com-
followingtreatmentwiththe1,4-dithianecomplex14 plexes with markedly different activities towards the
atvariousconcentrationsfor48 h.Thoughlowerthan leukemia cells.
for the bpm complex8, amuchstronger antiprolifer- A 10 lM solution of complex 11 induced a
ative effect was apparent in comparison to the poly- significant degree of apoptosis in Jurkat cells and
pyridylcomplexes7and11.Whilethepercentageof activation of mitrochondia-dependent caspase cas-
viable cells was similar to the percentage of late and cadesledtoPARPcleavagetothe89 kDaproductby
earlyapoptoticcellsfora10 lMsolution,novitalcells caspase-3. The 89 kDa fragment was much less
couldbedetectedata20 lMconcentration.Although intensive for a 20 lM solution and could not be
its antiproliferative properties are less pronounced at clearlyvisualizedataconcentrationof40 lMdespite
lower concentrations (\5 lM), the dithiane complex comparable loading. As this fragment just represents
14 exhibits similar apoptosis-inducing properties to aninitialstepinPARPcleavageanddegradationand
the bpm complex 8 at higher concentrations. As for the process of caspase-mediated apoptosis is accel-
the dpq complex 11, the Jurkat cells appear to be erated and/or enhanced at higher concentrations, it
significantly more sensitive towards 14 than are the can be assumed that further PARP degradation must
adhesive MCF-7 orHT-29cells.
Fig.5 WesternBlot(WB)analysesofJurkatcellsafter24h
Fig.4 AnnexinV/PIassaytowardsJurkatcellsillustratingthe treatment.aanti-PARP(top)with116kDaPARPand89kDa
number of cells/ml following their 48h treatment with the cleavedPARPandbWesternBlot:anti-b-actin(42kDa)used
compound [RhCl(dithiane)([9]aneS )]2? 14 at various asadetectorfortheappliedamountofproteinineachcase.NT
3
concentrations nottreated
123
Biometals(2011)24:645–661 653
have taken place for the 20 and 40 lM solutions of pronounced antileukemic activity were determined
11. For the effectively inactive compound 7 (see for Jurkatcells after 24and 48 h treatments.
Fig. 2), no significant PARP cleavage product of Significantly enhanced levels of intracellular ROS
89 kDa could be determined even at the higher were observed after 24 h treatments with each of the
concentrationsof20and40 lM.5 lMCamptothecin
was used as a positive probe for caspase-induced
apoptosis and PARP cleavage.
Measurements of reactive oxygen species (ROS)
An increase of intracellular reactive oxygen species
(ROS) is correlated to a deregulated mitochondrial
activity,whichisanadditionalindicationofapoptosis
induction and may reflect overall stress. The occur-
rence of ROS was measured for Jurkat cells by flow
cytometryanalysisandisshowninFigs. 6,7and8as
high and low ROS levels. After given incubation
periods, the detection marker dihydroethidium bro-
mide (DHE) was applied and the levels of high and
low ROS were measured by FACS (fluorescence-
activated cell sorting). The effects of the less active
complex7,andthethreecompounds8,11and14with
Fig.7 GenerationofreactiveoxygenspeciesinJurkatcellsin
the presence of [RhCl(bpm)([9]aneS )]2? 8 after incubation
3
timesofa24handb48h
Fig.6 Percentages of cells exhibiting high ROS levels in
Jurkatcellsinthepresenceof[RhCl(bpy)([9]aneS )]2?7and Fig.8 Percentages of cells exhibiting high ROS levels in
3
[RhCl(dpq)([9]aneS3)]2? 11 after incubation times of a 24h Jurkatcellsinthepresenceof[RhCl(1,4-dithiane)([9]aneS )]2?
3
andb48h 14afteranincubationtimeofa24handb48h
123
654 Biometals(2011)24:645–661
complexes at a 40 lM concentration. After a 48 h does not contain an aromatic diimino donor ligand,
incubation, the percentages of cells exhibiting high whose abilitiy to invoke ROS through either irradi-
ROS levels differed more strikingly than for the ation or through reactions with cellular reductants is
shorter time period (Fig. 6). Intracellular ROS were well-documented (Levina et al. 2009; Wang et al.
generated at significantly higher levels at all concen- 2010).
trations of 11. For compound 7, the increases in the
percentagescellsexhibitinghighROS(17–26%)now Cellular metabolism
correlated with increasing concentration. However
ROS levels did not significantly differ from those A cell-based sensor chip system was employed to
recorded after only 24 h. 11 is clearly more active monitor the influence of complexes 8 and 14 on the
than 7 after 48 h. 20 and 40 lM solutions of 11 metabolism of MCF-7 cells. This system allows the
induced high ROS levels for 70 and 74%ofthe cells online evaluation of the impedance of the cell layer,
(Fig. 6b), whereas CMPT only induced high ROS oxygen consumption and the extracellular acidificat-
levels in 52% of cells at a concentration of 20 lM. ion rate (glycolysis) of living cells over an extended
It is instructive to compare Fig. 6 with the results time span. Its silicon chip includes interdigitated
obtained for the potent bpm compound 8 after 24 electrodestructuresformeasuringthecellularimped-
and 48 h (Fig. 7). This also invoked increasing ance (Ehret et al. 1998), miniature Clarke-type
percentages of cells with high ROS levels with oxygenelectrodesformonitoringthecellularoxygen
increasing compound concentration. Whereas at a uptake (Wolf et al. 1998) and ion-sensitive field
1.25 lM concentration, 27% of the Jurkat cells effect transistors to record extracellular pH changes
already exhibited high ROS levels, this number rose (Lehmann et al. 2000).
to 83% for a 20 lM solution of 8 following a 48 h The impedance of the MCF-7 cell layers fell
incubation period (Fig. 7b). However, in striking rapidlyalmostimmediatelyaftertreatmentbeginwith
contrast to the less active dpq complex, the percent- 50 lM solutions of 8 and 14 and reached a steady
agesofcellsexhibitinghighROSlevelswerealready percentagelevelofabout25%ofitsinitialvalueafter
very high after 24 h and comparable to those 20 h in both cases (Fig. 9). This decrease indicated
observed for the longer incubation period. either morphological changes and/or changes in the
Figure 8 displays the concentration-dependent status of cellular adhesion properties, including cell–
percentages of Jurkat cells with high ROS levels cell and cell–matrix contacts, corresponding to the
after 24 and 48 h treatments with 14. Incubation of
the leukemia cells with a 10 lM solution of 14
induced threefold more cells with high ROS than
CMPT and at a concentration of 20 lM of 14 more
than 90% of the cells exhibited high ROS levels. As
alsoestablishedforthepotentcomplex8,noeffective
increase in the percentages of cells exhibiting high
ROSlevelswasobservedinthetimeperiod24–48 h.
In summary, a clear correlation between the
percentage of cells exhibiting high ROS levels and
the percentage of apoptotic cells was apparent after
48 h treatments with the potent complexes 8, 11 and
14. This finding is in accordance with studies that
have indicated that higher levels of reactive oxygen
species have a destructive effect on DNA and some
proteins and that the associated oxidative stress can
triggerapoptosis(Simonetal.2000;Sandstrometal. Fig.9 Standardcellimpedance(%)forMCF-7cellsovera38
hexposureperiodwith5and50lMsolutionsofcompounds5
1994). It is particularly interesting, that the aliphatic
and 8. The end of treatment is indicated by a vertical line.
1,4-dithiane complex 14 induced high ROS concen-
Measurements were continued for an additional 9h after
trations similar to those of complex 8, although it removalofthesubstances.RMrunningmedium
123
Biometals(2011)24:645–661 655
Fig.11 Standard extracellular acidification rates (%) for
Fig.10 Standard respiration rates (%) for MCF-7 cells over
MCF-7 cells over a 38h exposure period with 5 and 50lM
a 38h exposure period with 5 and 50lM solutions of
solutions of compounds 5 and 8. The end of treatment is
compounds 5 and 8. The end of treatment is indicated by a
indicatedbyaverticalline.Measurementswerecontinuedfor
vertical line. Measurements were continued for an additional
anadditional9hafterremovalofthesubstances.RMrunning
9hafterremovalofthesubstances.RMrunningmedium
medium
Extracellular acidification is closely linked to the
inductionofcelldeath.Theimpactof5 lMsolutions activity of glycolysis. This parameter is chiefly
first became apparent after 16 h. Aless rapiddecline influenced by lactic acid production, which is a
in the impedance of the cellular layer was then waste product of anaerobic metabolism. 50 lM
observedbutthiscontinuedduringthefinaldrugfree solutions of 8 and 14 both invoked significant
period (43–52 h), which indicated the infliction of decreases in the extracellular acidification rate for
permanent cellular damage at concentration levels MCF-7 cells within the first hours of treatment
close tothe IC values of8 and 14 (Figs. 3, 4). (Fig. 11), which indicates a lower cellular activity in
50
Oxygen consumption is generally indicative of comparison to nontreated cells. After reaching
enhanced or decreased mitochondrial activity (respi- minimum values of about 80–88% following treat-
ration).Otheroxygenconsumingprocessesaremuch ment for 20–30 h, the acidification rates increased
less efficient and thus unlikely to contribute signif- slowly for cells treated with 5 lM solutions of the
icantlytothissignal.FromFig. 10,itisapparentthat complexes during the final hours of treatment.
the oxygen consumption of the MCF-7 cells was Interestingly, an increase was also observed for the
dramatically affected during the first hours of treat- cellstreatedwiththe50 lMsolutionof8duringthis
ment with 50 lM solutions of 8 and 14 and fell to a period, although their acidification rate had fallen to
relative level of about only 10–15% after 16 and about only 35% of the original value after a 20 h
38 h, respectively. No recovery was observed in the exposure. All in all, the 38 h treatments had only a
final drug free phase. Significant decreases in the minor long-term effect on the extracellular acidifi-
respiration rates for the MCF-7 cells first became cation rate even at the higher concentration.
apparent during the second day of treatment
(28–43 h) with the 5 lM solutions. The relative
valuesonlyfelltoabout70and80%forcellstreated Conclusions
with 8 and 14, respectively, but no recovery was
observedduringthedrugfreeperiod.Thispermanent The complexes [RhCl(LL)([9]aneS )]2? with LL =
3
reduction in cell respiration correlates well with the bpm (8) and 1,4-dithiane (14) are potent antiprolif-
likewise dose-dependent increase in intracellular erativeagentstowardsbothadherentcancercellsand
ROS levels in Jurkat cells following their treatment non-adherent leukemia cells. In contrast, a total lack
with the complexes (Figs. 7, 8). of activity was established for the complexes 4 and
123
656 Biometals(2011)24:645–661
13 with the diamino chelate ligands 1,2-diaminoben- Materials and methods
zene (dab) and piperazine (pip), which suggests that
the presence of bidentate ligands with soft donor Chemicals
atoms may well be a prerequisite for high activity in
this type of complex. Reducing the overall charge RhCl (cid:2)3H OwaspurchasedfromABCR,1,4,7-trithia-
3 2
from?2to?1alsoledtoasignificantlossofactivity cyclononane, 9,10-diaminophenanthrene, sodium
for the complexes 5 and 6. dimethyldithiocarbamate, 2-phenylpyridine and CT
Complexes8and14induceapoptosisinJurkatcells DNAfromSigma–Aldrich,4,40-dicarboxy-2,20-bipyr-
but cause negligible necrosis. A high percentage of idine from TCI, 2,3-diaminonaphthalene from Acros
Jurkat cells exhibit high ROS levels after 24 h Organics, 1,2-phenylenediamine from Merck and
treatments with these complexes at concentrations in crystal violet from Roth. Concentrations of CT DNA
the 5–20 lM range and these percentages remain were determined spectrophotometrically using the
effectivelyconstantoverthenext24 h.AnnexinV/PI molar extinction coefficient e = 13,200 M-1 cm-1
260
assays indicate that the apoptosis levels are directly (Marmur1961).Solventsforsynthesiswereanalytical
correlated to the cellular ROS concentrations after reagentsgrade(JTBaker)andweredriedanddistilled
48 h, which suggests that the associated oxidative beforeuse.Deuteratedsolventsfor1HNMRmeasure-
stress must play a central role in the mechanism of mentswereobtainedfromDeuteroGmbH.
actionofthethiaethercomplexes.Cellularmetabolism
studies demonstrated that the apoptosis induction is
Instrumentation
time-dependent at concentrations close to the com-
pounds’ IC values. Cell death induction was first
50 UV/Vis spectra were recorded on an Analytik Jena
apparent after about 16 h but then increased steadily
SPECORD200,IRspectraonaNicoletImpact4000
over the following 24 h and during the drug free
spectrometer. A Jasco J-715 instrument was used to
period.Asimilartime-dependentpermanentdecrease
measure CD spectra for complex/CT DNA mixtures.
wasalsoestablishedforthecellularrespirationrate.
Liquidsecondaryionmasspectrometrydata(LSIMS)
Our present findings for complex 14 demonstrate
were registered on a Fisons VG Autospec employing
thatthepresenceofanaromaticdiiminochelateligand
acesiumiongun(17 kV),with3-nitrobenzylalcohol
is not essential for high antiproliferative activity but
astheliquidmatrix.ABrukerDRX400spectrometer
rather the presence of five soft donor atoms (i.e., 5
was used for the 1H NMR spectroscopic character-
thiaetherSatomsor3thiaetherSatomsplus2iminoN
ization of the new compounds, with chemical shifts
atoms) in the octahedral coordination sphere of the
reported as d values relative to the residual signal of
rhodium(III) atom. The similarity in the ROS levels
the deuterated solvent. The splitting of proton
invoked by the complexes 8 and 14 in Jurkat cells
resonances was defined as s = singlet, d = soublet,
despite their very different bidentate ligands sug-
m = multiplet. Elemental analyses were performed
geststhatspecificnon-covalentinteractionsinvolving
onaVarioELofElementarAnalysensystemeGmbH.
the[9]aneS coligandand/orkineticfactorsmayplay
3 Compounds 7–14 were prepared in accordance with
an important role in the mode of action of these
literature procedures (Bieda et al. 2009a, 2010).
rhodium(III)thiaethercomplexes.Duetotherestricted
abilityofitsadditionalthiaetherSatomstoneutralize
the high positive charge of the central rhodium(III) [RhCl(bpy-4,40-(COOH) )([9]aneS )]Cl (cid:2)H O 1
2 3 2 2
atoms through r donation (Brandt and Sheldrick
1996),asignificantlyslowerchloridesubstitutionrate 92.7 mg (0.38 mmol) 2,2-bpy-4,40-(COOH) were
2
will be expected for 14 in comparison to both the suspended in 20 ml ethanol and 100.2 mg
j2N(imino)complex8and,inparticular,theinactive (0.38 mmol) RhCl (cid:2)3H O, dissolved in 20 ml etha-
3 2
piperazinecomplex13withitsmoreeffectiveaminoN nol, were added and the colourless suspension was
r donor atoms. The slower decrease in MCF-7 cell refluxed at 100(cid:3)C for 2 h. Addition of 68.2 mg
adhesion and respiration caused by 14 versus 8 (0.38 mmol)[9]aneS totheresultingorangesolution
3
(Figs. 9,10)may,therefore,reflectitsslowerreaction followedbyrefluxingat100(cid:3)Cforafurther4 hledto
ratewithpossiblecellulartargetmolecules. formationofayellowsuspension.Afterfiltration,the
123
Biometals(2011)24:645–661 657
solution was reduced in volume to 5 ml and addition 5.27C27.0H4.53S18.02,found(%):N5.25C27.3H
of diethylether led to precipitation of the product 4.0 S 18.5; LSIMS m/z (%) = 461.0 (15) [M-Cl]?,
which was washed with EtOH and dried in vacuo. 425.0 (40) [M-Cl-HCl]?, 389.1 (93) [M-Cl-2HCl]?,
Yield: 198.9 mg (80%), C H N O Cl S Rh(cid:2)H O 281.1(23)[M-Cl-2HCl-dab]?,329.1(17)[M-Cl-2HCl-
18 20 2 4 3 3 2
(651.85 g/mol) calcd. (%): N 4.30 C 33.17 H 3.4 S (CH CH S)]?,1H-NMR(DMSO-d ,400 MHz,25(cid:3)C):
2 2 6
14.76, found (%): N 4.1 C33.1 H 3.4 S 14.5; LSIMS d = 3.13–3.85(m,12H,CH [9]aneS ),7.17–7.75(m,
2 3
m/z (%) = 561.9 (87) [M-Cl-HCl]?, 526.9 (28) [M- 4H,dab)ppm.
Cl-2HCl]?, 497.9 (43) [M-Cl-HCl-CH CH ]?, 465.9
2 2
(15)[M-Cl-HCl-SCH CH ]?,437.9(23)[M-Cl-HCl-
2 2 [RhCl(dmdtc)([9]aneS )](CF SO )(cid:2)2H O 5
S(CH CH ) ]?; 1H-NMR (MeOH-d4, 400 MHz, 3 3 3 2
2 2 2
25(cid:3)C): d = 3.05–3.89 (m, 12 H, CH [9]aneS ),
2 3 100 mg (0.18 mmol) of [RhCl (MeCN)([9]aneS )]
8.26 (d, 2H, H3/H8), 9.25 (dd, 2H, H2/H9) 9.37 2 3
(CF SO )(cid:2)1.5 H O [30] were dissolved in 15 ml
(s, 2H, H5/H6) ppm. 3 3 2
MeOH and 33.2 mg of Na[S CNMe ] (0.18 mmol),
2 2
dissolved in 2 ml MeOH, were added. The reaction
[RhCl(phi)([9]aneS )]Cl (cid:2)1.5H O 2
3 2 2 mixture was refluxed for 3 h. Following filtration of
the yellow precipitate and volume reduction of the
Preparation as for [RhCl(bpy)([9]aneS )]Cl [28]
3 2 remainingorangesolutionto5 ml,additionofdiethyl
with 77.1 mg of phi (0.38 mmol), suspended in
ether led to precipitation of the product, which was
10 ml CH Cl /EtOH/CH Cl (4/2/1). Yield: 170 mg
2 2 3 washed with MeOH and dried in vacuo. Yield:
(72%); C H Cl N S Rh (cid:2)1.5H O (622.89 g/mol)
20 22 3 2 3 1 2 66.7 mg (61%), C H ClNO S F Rh(cid:2)2H O (622.85
calcd. (%): N 4.5 C 38.56 H 4.05 S 15.4, found 10 18 3 6 3 2
g/mol) calcd. (%): N 2.24 C 19.25 H 3.55 S 30.83,
(%) N 3.7 C 38.8 H 4.0 S 14.9; LSIMS m/z
found (%): N 1.8 C 18.8 H 3.1 S 30.4; LSIMS m/z
(%) = 595.3 (14) [M-H]?, 524.3 (15) [M-Cl-HCl]?,
(%) = 437.8 (100) [M-OTf]?, 402.8 (44) [M-HOTf-
443.3 (100) [M-S (CH CH ) ]?, 414.2 (56) [M-
3 2 2 2 Cl]? 374.8 (13) [M-HOTf-Cl-CH CH ]? 345.8 (4)
[9]aneS -H]?, 1H-NMR (CD Cl , 400 MHz, 25(cid:3)C): 2 2
3 2 2 [M-HOTf-Cl-(CH CH ) ]?, 314.8 (13) [M-HOTf-
d = 2.90–4.01 (m, 12H, CH [9]aneS ), 7.49 (t, 2H, 2 2 2
2 3 Cl–S(CH CH ) ]?, 1H-NMR (CD CN, 400 MHz,
H3/H8),7.74(t,2H, H4/H7), 8.05–8.20(2d,4H,H2/ 2 2 2 3
25(cid:3)C): d = 3.19 (s, 6H, CH carbamate), 3.16–3.22
H9, H5/H6) ppm. 3
(m, 8H, CH [9]aneS ), 3.34–3.46 (m, 4H, CH
2 3 2
[9]aneS ) ppm.
[RhCl(naphdiamine)([9]aneS )]Cl (cid:2)H O 3 3
3 2 2
Preparation as for [RhCl(dpq)([9]aneS )]Cl [28] [RhCl(phenylpy)([9]aneS )]Cl(cid:2)3H O 6
3 2 3 2
with 60.1 mg 2,3-diaminonaphthalene (0.38 mmol),
dissolved in 10 ml CH Cl . Yield: 86.4 mg (40%), 500 ll 30% NaOMe (0.38 mmol) were added to
2 2
C H N Cl Rh S (cid:2)H O (565.82 g/mol) calcd. (%): 54.3 ll 2-phenylpyridine (0.38 mmol) and were
16 22 2 3 1 3 2
N 4.95 C 33.96 H 4.28 S 17.0, found (%): N 4.6 C stirred at 37(cid:3)C for 24 h. 100 mg of RhCl (cid:2)3H O
3 2
33.9H4.6S17.1;LSIMSm/z(%) = 511.0(34)[M- (0.38 mmol)dissolvedin30 mlMeOH/CH Cl (1/1)
2 2
Cl]?, 475 (78) [M-Cl-HCl]?, 439.1 (32) [M-Cl- was added and the reaction mixture was heated for
2HCl]?, 489.1 (100) [M-SCH CH ?2H]?, 1H-NMR 2 h in boiling MeOH/CH Cl After addition of
2 2 2 2.
(DMSO-d , 400 MHz, 25(cid:3)C): d = 3.70–3.90 (m, 68.4 mg of [9]aneS (0.38 mmol), the resulting
6 3
12H, CH [9]aneS ), 7.50–7.60 (m, 2H), 7.90–8.05 suspension was refluxed for a further 5 h. Following
2 3
(m, 4H) ppm. filtration of the yellow precipitate ([RhCl ([9]ane
3
S )])andvolumereductionoftheremainingsolution
3
[RhCl(dab)([9]aneS )]Cl (cid:2)2H O 4 to 5 ml, addition of diethyl ether led to precipitation
3 2 2
oftheproduct,whichwaswashedwithH Oanddried
2
Preparationasfor[RhCl(bpy)([9]aneS )]Cl [28]with in vacuo. Yield: 25.2 mg (72%), C H NCl S Rh (cid:2)
3 2 17 20 2 3 1
41.6 mg2-phenylenediamine(dab)(0.38 mmol),dis- 3H O (562.4 g/mol) calcd. (%): N 2.49 C 36.31 H
2
solvedin10 mlMeOH/CH Cl .Yield:42.5 mg(21%), 4.66 S 17.1, found (%): N 2.45 C 36.51 H 4.61 S
2 2
C H Cl N S Rh(cid:2)2H O(533.79 g/mol)calcd.(%):N 16.45; LSIMS m/z (%) = 471.9 (100) [M-Cl]?,
12 20 3 2 3 2
123
658 Biometals(2011)24:645–661
437.1 (6) [M-Cl-HCl]?, 1H-NMR (D O ? NaCl, 5% CO for 72 h (MCF-7), or 48 h (HT-29 or HEK-
2 2
400 MHz, 25(cid:3)C): d = 3.4–3.75 (m, 12H, CH 293).InanalogytotheprocedureforMCF-7andHT-
2
[9]aneS ), 7.28–7.53 (m, 3H, H3/H7/H8), 7.77 (d, 29 cells, one plate was subsequently used for the
3
1H, H6), 7.95 (dd, 1H, H5), 8.12 (t, 1H, H4), 8.27 determination of the initial HEK-293 cell biomass.
(d, 1H, H9), 8.74 (d, 1H, H2) ppm. Following removal of the medium, the HEK-293
cells were fixed by a 20–30 min incubation with
100 ll glutardialdehyde solution (1 ml glutardialde-
Biological investigations
hyde in 25 ml PBS, pH 7.3). The solution was
removed,180 llPBSwereaddedandtheplatestored
Cell cultures
at 4(cid:3)C until further treatment. Stock solutions of the
compounds 1–6 in DMF were freshly prepared and
MCF-7 breast adenocarcinoma and HT-29 colon
diluted with cell culture medium to the desired
carcinoma cells were maintained in DMEM High
concentrations (final DMF concentration: 0.1% v/v).
Glucose (PAA) supplemented with 50 mg l-1 genta-
Themediumintheplateswasreplacedwithmedium
mycinand10%(v/v)fetalcalfserum(FCS)at37(cid:3)C/
containing the compounds at graded concentrations
5% CO and passaged once a week according to
2 (six replicates). After further incubation for 96 h
standard procedures. For HEK-293 cells, Dulbecco’s
(MCF-7), 72 h (HT-29) or 96 h (HEK-293), the
modified eagle medium (Invitrogen) supplemented
medium was removed and the plates treated with
with 10% fetal bovine serum and 100 units/ml
glutardialdehyde and PBS as described above. The
penicillin and streptomycin was employed at 37(cid:3)C/
cell biomass was determined for HEK-293 and
5% CO . The cells were split and aliquots were
2 the other cells by crystal violet staining using the
seeded in 35 mm culture dishes three times a week.
following procedure. Firstly, the PBS was removed
Burkitt-like lymphoma BJAB cells were maintained
before addition of 100 ll of 0.02 M crystal violet
at 37(cid:3)C in RPMI 1640 (GIBCO, Invitrogen) supple-
solution and the plates were incubated for 30 min.
mented with 10% heat-inactivated FCS, penicil-
The crystal violet solution was subsequently
lin (100,000 U l-1), streptomycin (0.1 g l-1) and
removed, and the fixed cells were then washed twice
L-glutamine (0.56 g l-1). The cells were subcultured
with water and exposed to water for 15 min. The
every 3–4 days by dilution of the cells to a concen-
water was removed and the crystal violet extracted
tration of 1 9 105 cells ml-1. Twenty-four hours
fromtheadherentcellbiomassbyshakingfor3 hon
before the assay setup, cells were cultured at a
a softly rocking rotary shaker with 180 ll of 70%
concentration of 3 9 105 cells ml-1 to ascertain
ethanol. The absorption was then determined at
standardized growth conditions. For the apoptosis
590 nm using a Fusion a multiwell-plate reader
assays, the cells were then diluted to a concentration
(Perkin–Elmer) for HEK-293 cells, or a Victor X4
of 1 9 105 cells ml-1 immediately before addition
2030 Multilabel Reader for MCF-7 and HT-29 cells.
of the complexes.
The mean absorption of the initial biomass plate was
subtracted from the mean absorption of each exper-
Antiproliferative activity measurements iment and control. IC values were determined as
50
those concentrations causing 50% inhibition of cell
The antiproliferative effects of the compounds were proliferation. Results were calculated from 2 to 3
determinedbyanestablishedprocedurefortheMCF- independent experiments.
7 and HT-29 cells (Ott et al. 2005). An adaption of
the procedure was employed for the HEK-293 cells Annexin-V propidium iodide binding assay
(Bieda et al. 2010). Initial determination of a growth for Jurkat and K562 cells
curve led to the HEK-293 specific parameters of cell
concentration and incubation periods. Cells were Jurkat cells were purchased from German Collection
suspended in cell culture medium (MCF-7: of Microorganisms and Cell Culture (DSMZ, Braun-
10000 cells ml-1; HT-29: 2,850 cells ml-1; HEK- schweig, No AA 282, LOT 7). The cells were
293: 2,000 cells ml-1) and 100 ll aliquots thereof maintained in RPMI 1640 (PAA) medium supple-
were plated in 96 well-plates and incubated at 37(cid:3)C/ mentedwith10%fetalcalfserum(FCS,PAA),37(cid:3)C,
123
Biometals(2011)24:645–661 659
5% CO and maximum humidity. Jurkat/K562 cells (Becton–Dickinson) and CellQuest Pro (BD) analy-
2
were cultivated in standard conditions. sis software. Excitation and emission settings were
After harvesting Jurkat cells/K562 cells and an 488 nm and 564–606 nm (FL2 filter), respectively.
incubation period of either 24 or 48 h, the cells were The region of ‘low’- and ‘high’- ROS on histogram
washed in cold phosphate-buffered saline (PBS). plot were determined according to the correspond-
Negative controls were prepared by incubating cells ing control samples.
in the absence of inducing agent. After resuspension
at a concentration of 1 9 106 cells/ml in an annexin
Cellular metabolism
binding buffer (10 mM HEPES, 140 mM NaCl, and
2.5 mM CaCl , pH 7.4.), 100 ll of this suspension
2 Changes in cellular metabolism and morphology
were prepared to provide a sufficient volume per
were analyzed using a Bionas 2500 sensor chip
assay. 5 ll of the annexin V conjugate (in 25 mM
system(Bionas,Rostock,Germany).Thesensorchip
HEPES, 140 mM NaCl, 1 mM EDTA, pH 7.4, plus
(SC1000) enables continuous measurement of oxy-
0.1% bovine serum albumin (BSA); obtained from
gen consumption using oxygen-sensitive electrodes
Invitrogen) were added together with the dead-cell
(Wolf et al. 1998), pH changes of the medium by
indicator such as propidium iodide (SYTOX(cid:4) Green
employing ion-sensitive field effect transistors
dye) to each 100 ll of cell suspension. After an
(Lehmann et al. 2000) and the impedance between
incubationperiodof15 minatroomtemperature,the
two interdigitated electrode structures (Ehret et al.
cells were analyzed by flow cytometry using a
1998) to register the impedance under and across the
FACS(cid:4)Calibur (Becton–Dickinson) and the Cell-
cell layer on the chip surface. Before measurement,
Quest Pro (BD) analysis software.
cells were seeded on the sensor chip in DMEM
(PAA, E15-883) with penicillin/streptomycin and
PARP cleavage
10% (v/v) FCS (PAA) and incubated in a standard
tissue culture incubator at 37(cid:3)C/5% CO and 95%
Jurkatcellswereincubatedwithdifferentamountsof 2
humidityfor24 huntil90%confluencywasreached.
selected compounds for 24 h. Cell lysing and
Sensor chips with cells were then transferred to the
analyzing were performed in a 10% SDS–PAGE.
Bionas 2500 analyzer in which medium is continu-
Proteins were transferred on Immobilon-P Transfer
ously exchanged in 10 min cycles (3 min exchange
membranes (Milipore) and the immune blotting was
ofmediumand7 minwithoutflow)duringwhichthe
performed with anti-PARP rabbits polyclonal anti-
parameters were measured. The running medium
bodies. For the signal detection a western blot
used during the analysis was DMEM without car-
lightning ECL-reagent and a LAS 3000 Imaging
bonated buffer (PAN Cat. Nr. P03-0010) and only
system (Fuji) were used.
weakly buffered with 1 mM Hepes, reduced FCS
(0.1%) and low glucose (1 g l-1). For drug activity
Measurement of intracellular ROS
testing, the following steps were followed: (a) 5 h
towards the Jurkat and K562 cell lines
equilibration with running medium with 3 and 7 min
stop/flow incubation intervals, (b) 38 h drug incuba-
Jurkat cells were cultivated in standard conditions
tion with substances freshly dissolved in medium at
during the treatment and the cells were treated with
indicated concentrations also with the same stop/
indicated concentrations of the substances for 3 and
flow,and(c)a9 hstepinwhichthecellswereagain
9 h. Cells were collected at given time points,
fed with running medium without substances. At the
centrifuged at 0.2 g (1,500 rpm) and resuspended in
endofeachexperiment,cellswerekilledbyaddition
FACS buffer (D-PBS, Gibco, ?1% BSA, PAA).
of0.2%TritonX-100toobtainabasicsignalwithout
The cell suspension was incubated with DHE
living cells on the sensor surface with as a negative
(dihydroethidium, SIGMA, 5 ll of 5 mM stock
control.
solution per 1 ml of cell suspension containing
106 cells) at room temperature in the dark for
Acknowledgments Financial support for this work in
15 min., washed once more with FACS buffer and
Bochum, Braunschweig and Heidelberg by the Deutsche
immediately analysed using a FACS(cid:4)Calibur Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) within the research group
123
660 Biometals(2011)24:645–661
FOR630‘‘Biologicalfunctionoforganometalliccompounds’’is acid)(dppz)]n? (dppz=dipyrido[3,2-a:20,30-c]phenazine),
gratefullyacknowledged.RuthBiedawishestothanktheRuhr n=1-3.JChemSocDaltonTrans,3664–3673
UniversityResearchSchoolfortheawardofascholarship. Harlos M, Ott I, Gust R, Alborzinia H, Wo¨lfl S, Kromm A,
Sheldrick WS (2008) Synthesis, biological activity, and
structure-activity relationships for potent cytotoxic rho-
dium(III) polypyridyl complexes. J Med Chem 51:
3924–3933
References Hartinger CG, Zorbas-Seifried S, Jakupec MA, Kynast B,
Zorbas H, Keppler BK (2006) From bench to bedside—
Andree HA, Reutelingsperger CP, Hauptmann HC, Hemker preclinical and early clinical development of the anti-
HC, Hermens WT, Willems GM (1990) Binding of vas- cancer agent imidazolium trans-[tetrachlorobis(1H-inda-
cular anticoagulant-alpha (vac-alpha) to planar phospho- zole)ruthenium(III)] (KP1019 or FFC14A). J Inorg
lipid-bilayers.JBiolChem265:4923–4928 Biochem100:891–904
Annen P, Schildberg S, Sheldrick WS (2000) HerebianD,SheldrickWS(2002)SynthesisandDNAbinding
(g5-Pentamethylcyclopentadienyl)iridium(III) complexes properties of bioorganometallic (pentamethylcyclopentad
ofpurinenucleobasesandnucleotides:acomparisonwith ienyl)iridium(III) complexes of the type [(C 5 Me 5 )Ir(-
(g6-arene)ruthenium(II) and (g5-pentamethylcyclopenta- Aa)(dppz)]n? (dppz=dipyrido[3,2-a:20,30-c]-phenazine,
dienyl)rhodium(III) species. Inorg Chim Acta 307:115– n=1-3), with S-coordinated amino acids (Aa) or pep-
124 tides.JChemSocDaltonTrans966–974
Bieda R, Ott I, Dobroschke M, Prokop A, Gust R, Sheldrick Jakupec MA, Galanski M, Arion VB, Hartinger CG, Keppler
WS (2009a) Structure-activity relationships and DNA BK(2008)Antitumormetalcomplexes:morethantheme
binding properties of apoptosis inducing cytotoxic rho- andvariations.DaltonTrans,183–194
dium(III) polypyridyl complexes containing the cyclic KapitzaS,JakupecMA,UhlM,KepplerBK,MarianB(2005)
thioether[9]aneS .JInorgBiochem103:698–708 The heterocyclic ruthenium(III) complex KP1019
3
BiedaR,OttI,GustR,SheldrickWS(2009b)Cytotoxicrho- (FFC14A) causes DNA damage and oxidative stress in
dium(III) polypyridyl complexes containing the tris(pyr- colorectaltumorcells.CancerLetts226:115–121
azolyl)methane coligand: synthesis, DNA binding Koopman G, Reutelingsperger CPM, Kuijten GAM, Keehnen
propertiesandstructure-activityrelationships.EurJInorg RMJ,PalsST,vanOersMHJ(1994)Annexin-Vforflow
Chem3821–3831 cytometric detectionofphosphatidylserine expression on
Bieda R, Dobroschke M, Triller A, Ott I, Spehr M, Gust R, B-cellsundergoingapoptosis.Blood84:1415–1420
ProkopA,SheldrickWS(2010)Cell-selective,apoptosis- Lecoeur H (2002) Nuclear apoptosis detection by flow
inducing rhodium(III) crown thiaether complexes. cytometry: influence of endogenous endonucleases. Exp
ChemMedChem5:1123–1133 CellRes277:1–14
Brabec V, Kleinwa¨chter V, Butour J-L, Johnson NP (1990) Lehmann M,BaumannW, Brischwein M,EhretR, KrausM,
Biophysical studies of the modification of DNA by anti- SchwindeA,BitzehoferM,FreudI,WolfB(2000)Non-
tumor platinum coordination complexes. Biophys Chem invasivemeasurementofcellmembraneassociatedproton
25:129–141 gradientsbyion-sensitivefieldeffecttransistorarraysfor
BrandtK,SheldrickWS(1996)Synthesis,structureandreac- microphysiologicalandbioelectronicalapplications.Bio-
tivity of the thioether half-sandwich rhodium complex sensBioelectron15:117–124
[RhCl(MeCN) ([9]aneS )][CF SO ] .JChemSocDalton Levina A, Mitra A, Lay PA (2009) Recent developments in
2 3 3 32
Trans1237–1243 rutheniumanticancerdrugs.Metallomics1:458–470
Clarke M (2002) Ruthenium metallopharmaceuticals. Coord MadureiraJ,SantosTM,GoodfellowBJ,LucenaM,Pedrossade
ChemRev232:69–93 JesusJ,Santana-MarquesMG,DrewMGB,FelixY(2000)
Dobroschke M, Geldmacher Y, Ott I, Harlos M, Kater L, Structural characterisation of new Ru-II[9]aneS(3) poly-
Wagner L, Gust R, Sheldrick WS (2009) Cytotoxic rho- pyridylcomplexes.JChemSocDaltonTrans4422–4431
dium(III) and iridium(III) polypyridyl complexes: struc- Marmur J (1961) Procedure for isolation of deoxyribonucleic
ture-activity relationships, antileukemic activity, and acidfrommicro-organisms.JMolBiol3:208–218
apoptosisinduction.ChemMedChem4:177–187 Medvetz DA, Stakleff KD, Schreiber T, Custer PD, Hindi K,
Ehret R, Baumann W, Brischwein M, Schwinde A, Wolf B PanznerMJ,BlancoD,TaschnerMJ,TessierCA,Youngs
(1998)Onlinecontrolofcellularadhesionwithimpedance WJ (2007) Ovarian cancer activity of cyclic amines and
measurements using interdigitated electrode structures. thiaethermetalcomplexes.JMedChem50:1703–1706
MedBiolEngComput36:365–370 MenonEL,PereaR,NavarroM,KuhnRJ,MorrisonH(2004)
ErikssonM,NordenB(2001)Linearandcirculardichroismof Phototoxicityagainsttumorcellsandsindbisvirusbyan
drug-nucleic acid complexes. Methods Enzymol 340: octahedral rhodiumbispyridyl complex and evidence for
60–98 the genome as a target in viral photoinactivation. Inorg
Erkkila KE, Odom DT, Barton JK (1999) Recognition and Chem43:5373–5381
reaction of metallointercalators with DNA. Chem Rev Metcalfe C, Thomas JA (2003) Kinetically inert transition
99:2777–2795 metalcomplexesthatreversiblybindtoDNA.ChemSoc
FrodlA,HerebianD,SheldrickWS(2002)Coligandtuningofthe Rev32:215–224
DNAbindingpropertiesofbioorganometallic(arene)ruthe- MorbidelliL,DonniniS,FilippiS,MessoriL,PiccioliF,Orioli
nium(II) complexes of the type [(arene)Ru(amino P, Sava G,Ziche M(2003)Antiangiogenic properties of
123
Biometals(2011)24:645–661 661
selected ruthenium(III) complexes that are nitric oxide [L=Cl, n=1; L=(NH ) CS, n=2]. Eur J Inorg
22
scavengers.BrJCancer88:1481–1491 Chem3034–3046
Nicholson DW, Ali A, Thornberry NA, Vallancourt JP, Ding Scharwitz MA, Ott I, Geldmacher Y, Gust R, Sheldrick WS
CK,GallantM(1995)Identificationandinhibitionofthe (2008) Cytotoxic half-sandwich rhodium(III) complexes:
ice/ced-3 protease necessary for mammalian apoptosis. polypyridylligandinfluenceontheirDNAbindingprop-
Nature376:37–43 erties and cellular uptake. J Organomet Chem 693:
Ott I, Gust R (2007) Non platinum metal complexes as anti- 2299–2309
cancerdrugs.ArchPharmChemLifeSci340:117–126 SheldrickWS,Hagen-EckhardHS,HeebS(1993)Preparation
OttI,SchmidtK,KircherB,SchuhmacherP,WiglendaT,Gust and structural characterization of tetranuclear (g6-ben-
R (2005) Antitumor-active cobalt-alkyne complexes zene)ruthenium(II) complexes with bridging N-donor
derivedfromacetylsalicyclicacid.Studiesofthemodeof atoms.InorgChimActa206:15–21
drugaction.JMedChem48:622–629 Shields TP, Barton JK (1995) Sequence-selective DNA rec-
Pruchnik FP, Jakimowicz P, Ciunik Z, Zakrzewska-Czer- ognition and photocleavage—a comparison of enantio-
winska J, Opolski A, Wietrzyk J, Wojdat E (2002)Rho- mersofRh(en)2Phi(3?).Biochemistry34:15037–15048
dium(III) complexes with polypyridyls and pyrazole and Simon H-U, Hai-Yehia A, Levi-Scha¨fer F (2000) Role of
theirantitumoractivity.InorgChimActa334:59–66 reactive oxygen species (ROS) in apoptosis induction.
Rademaker-LakhaiJM,VandenBongardD,PluimD,Beijnen Apoptosis5:418–425
JH,SchellensJHM(2004)AphaseIandpharmocological Sitlani A, Long EC, Pyle AM, Barton JK (1992) DNA
study with imidazolium-trans-DMSO-imidazole-tetra- photocleavage by phenanthrenequinone diimine com-
chlororuthenate—anovelrutheniumanticanceragent.Clin plexes of rhodium(III)—shape-selective recognition and
CancerRes10:3717–3727 reaction.JAmChemSoc114:2303–2312
RiccardiC,NicolettiI(2006)Analysisofapoptosisbypropi- Van Engeland M, Nieland LJW, Ramaekers FCS, Schutte B,
dium iodide staining and flow cytometry. Nat Protoc ReutelingspergerCPM(1998)AnnexinV-affinityassay:a
1:1458–1461 review on an apoptosis detection system based on phos-
Rosenberg B, VanCamp L, Trosko JE, Mansour VH (1969) phatidylserineexposure.Cytometry31:1–9
Platinum compounds—a new class of antitumor agents. WangY,ZhangX,ZhangQ,YangZ(2010)Oxidativedamage
Nature222:385 to DNA by 1, 10-phenanthroline/L-threonine copper(II)
Sandstrom PA, Mannie MD, Buttke TM (1994) Inhibition of complexeswithchlorogenicacid.Biometals23:265–273
activation-induced death in T-cell hybridomas by thiol WolfB,BrischweinM,BaumannW,EhretR,KrausM(1998)
antioxidants—oxidativestressasamediatorofapoptosis. Monitoring of cellular signaling and metabolism with
JLeukocBiol55:221–226 modularservertechnique:thePhysioControlMicrosystem
Scha¨ferS,OttI,GustR,SheldrickWS(2007)Influenceofthe (PCM).BiosensBioelectron13:501–509
polypyridyl (pp) ligand size on the DNA binding prop- ZeglisBM,PierreVC,BartonJK(2007)Metallo-intercalators
erties, cytotoxicity and cellular uptake of organorutheni- andmetallo-insertors.ChemCommun4565–4579
um(II) complexes of the type [(C Me )Ru(L)(pp)]n?
6 6
123